REASON MAGAZINE::REASON ONLINE
Jacob Sullum, Senior Editor, Reason Magazine | February 7, 2007
Although Stephen Lawrence and John Lefebvre are charged with money laundering, there was nothing sneaky about their “conspiracy.” In 1999 the two Canadians co-founded Neteller, an online payment processing company, now based in the Isle of Man, that openly specialized in serving online gamblers.
The FBI’s investigation of Lawrence and Lefebvre, who were arrested last month and face a preliminary hearing in New York next week, consisted mainly of reading their public statements and using Neteller to bet on a couple of football games—a vice that in this country has to rank up there with eating a second slice of Mom’s apple pie while listening to The Star-Spangled Banner. Yes, the feds really blew the lid off this publicly traded company that never made a secret of who its customers were or what it did for them.
The impressive thing about the case, part of the Justice Department’s legally shaky crusade against online gambling, is not the evidence but the government’s sinister spin on it. The feds pretend they’re pursuing criminals while prosecuting honest businessmen for providing services Americans want.
The money laundering charges against Lawrence and Lefebvre—which carry prison sentences of up to 20 years, 10 times the maximum penalty for the offense they supposedly facilitated—are based on the government’s claim that Neteller transferred money into and out of the United States “with the intent to promote the carrying on of specified unlawful activity.” According to Michael Garcia, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, the “unlawful activity” was taking online bets from Americans, which he describes as “a colossal criminal enterprise masquerading as legitimate business.”
Others, including the millions of Americans who use the Internet to bet on sports or play games of chance, the companies that serve them, and the foreign governments that license and regulate the companies, see things differently. They see a legitimate business that bluenoses with badges are determined to tar as a criminal enterprise because they can’t stand the idea that somebody in Westchester County might be playing poker in his pajamas.