• Same Song, Second Verse - Prohibition II: Good Grief

    18 October 2006

    Newspaper

    MSNBC – Newsweek
    By George F. Will
    Newsweek

    Oct. 23, 2006 issue – Perhaps Prohibition II is being launched because Prohibition I worked so well at getting rid of gin. Or maybe the point is to reassure social conservatives that Republicans remain resolved to purify Americans’ behavior. Incorrigible cynics will say Prohibition II is being undertaken because someone stands to make money from interfering with other people making money.

    For whatever reason, last Friday the president signed into law Prohibition II. You almost have to admire the government’s plucky refusal to heed history’s warnings about the probable futility of this adventure. This time the government is prohibiting Internet gambling by making it illegal for banks or credit-card companies to process payments to online gambling operations on a list the government will prepare.

    Last year about 12 million Americans wagered $6 billion online. But after Congress, 32 minutes before adjourning, passed its ban, the stock of the largest online-gambling business, Gibraltar-based PartyGaming, which gets 85 percent of its $1 billion annual revenue from Americans, declined 58 percent in one day, wiping out about $5 billion in market value…..

    The stock of a British company, World Gaming PLC, which gets about 95 percent of its revenue from Americans, plunged 88 percent. The industry, which has some 2,300 Web sites and did half of its business last year with Americans, has lost $8 billion in market value because of the new law. And you thought the 109th Congress did not accomplish anything.

    Supporters of the new law say it merely strengthens enforcement; they claim that Internet gambling is illegal under the Wire Act enacted in 1961, before Al Gore, who was then 13, had invented the Internet. But not all courts agree. Supporters of the new law say online gambling sends billions of dollars overseas. But the way to keep the money here is to decriminalize the activity.

    The number of online American gamblers, although just one sixth the number of Americans who visit real casinos annually, doubled in the last year. This competition alarms the nation’s biggest gambling interests—state governments.

    It is an iron law: When government uses laws, tariffs and regulations to restrict the choices of Americans, ostensibly for their own good, someone is going to make money from the paternalism. One of the big winners from the government’s action against online gambling will be the state governments that are America’s most relentless promoters of gambling. Forty-eight states (all but Hawaii and Utah) have some form of legalized gambling. Forty-two states have lottery monopolies. Thirty-four states rake in part of the take from casino gambling, slot machines or video poker.

    The new law actually legalizes online betting on horse racing, Internet state lotteries and some fantasy sports. The horse-racing industry is a powerful interest. The solidarity of the political class prevents the federal officials from interfering with state officials’ lucrative gambling. And woe unto the politicians who get between a sports fan and his fun.
    Story continues below ↓ advertisement

    In the private sector, where realism prevails, casino operators are not hot for criminalizing Internet gambling. This is so for two reasons: It is not in their interest for government to wax censorious. And online gambling might whet the appetites of millions for the real casino experience.

    Granted, some people gamble too much. And some people eat too many cheeseburgers. But who wants to live in a society that protects the weak-willed by criminalizing cheeseburgers? Besides, the problems—frequently exaggerated—of criminal involvement in gambling, and of underage and addictive gamblers, can be best dealt with by legalization and regulation utilizing new software solutions. Furthermore, taxation of online poker and other gambling could generate billions for governments.

    Prohibition I was a porous wall between Americans and their martinis, giving rise to bad gin supplied by bad people. Prohibition II will provoke imaginative evasions as the market supplies what gamblers will demand—payment methods beyond the reach of Congress.

    But governments and sundry busybodies seem affronted by the Internet, as they are by any unregulated sphere of life. The speech police are itching to bring bloggers under campaign-finance laws that control the quantity, content and timing of political discourse. And now, by banning a particular behavior—the entertainment some people choose, using their own money—government has advanced its mother-hen agenda of putting a saddle and bridle on the Internet.

    Gambling is, however, as American as the Gold Rush or, for that matter, Wall Street. George Washington deplored the rampant gambling at Valley Forge, but lotteries helped fund his army as well as Harvard, Princeton and Dartmouth. And Washington endorsed the lottery that helped fund construction of the city that now bears his name, and from which has come a stern—but interestingly selective—disapproval of gambling.
    © 2006 Newsweek, Inc.

    Related News

    • 15 July 2019

      Yggdrasil Premieres Trolls Bridge 2, the Sequel to Hugely Successful Slot

      Provider of inventive software solutions, Yggdrasil, has shared some big news with their countless fans all across the globe: the iconic Trolls Bridge slot game is getting its long-awaited sequel! This feature-packed title and successor to one of the company's most successful games again boasts a set of “playful and devious characters that will help hoard giant wins.” Familiar, But Still Different:

      Read full article
    • 24 August 2018

      New Leprechaun Song Slot Released by Pragmatic Play

      After players have been waiting for quite a while in anticipation, Pragmatic Play has finally released their latest online slot. This game is Leprechaun Song, and it's a title produced with winning some serious cash in mind without letting the volatility get too far out of hand. This helps to make it a good balance between the two major play styles that people tend to prefer. What the Leprechaun Song Slot Offers

      Read full article
    • 26 March 2018

      Net Entertainment Pays Two Six-Figure Jackpots on the Same Day

      One of the things that Net Entertainment is known for is their great selection of progressive slots. The games that use the Mega Fortune set of jackpots are a great example of this. Recently, this company made history by paying out the same jackpot twice in one day to give a pair of lucky players life-changing sums of money, and they both came from the Mega Fortune Dreams game. Two Big Jackpots One of the two jackpots was won by a player from the United Kingdom.

      Read full article